11.27.12

6 West Coast Senators Urge DOJ to Investigate Western Gas Price Spikes

Senators Call for ‘Refinery-by-Refinery Probe’

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Today, the six senators from Washington, Oregon, and California demanded that the Department of Justice (DOJ) conduct a refinery-by-refinery investigation into the cause of spikes that drove gas prices to more than $4 a gallon in Western states during May and October.

In a letter sent today to Attorney General Eric Holder, the Senators called on the Department of Justice’s Oil and Gas Price Fraud Working Group to investigate whether market manipulation or false reporting by oil refineries contributed to near-record gas prices on the West Coast earlier this year.

The letter was sent by Senators Maria Cantwell (D-WA,) Ron Wyden (D-OR), Dianne Feinstein (D-CA), Patty Murray (D-WA), Barbara Boxer (D-CA), and Jeff Merkley (D-OR).

“We are requesting a Department of Justice investigation of possible market manipulation and false reporting by oil refineries which may have created a perception of a supply shortage, when in fact refineries were still producing,” the six Senators wrote. “A McCullough Research report released Nov. 15th in conjunction with a California State Senate hearing on California gas prices revealed information that showed that the price spikes in May and October occurred while crude oil prices were declining, inventories were increasing, and possibly in conjunction with misleading market-making information.  We hope the Justice Department and members of the Oil and Gas Price Fraud Working Group will launch a refinery-by-refinery level probe.”

The letter comes on the heels of a report from McCullough Research indicating that some West Coast oil refineries may have been producing oil last May despite public reports that they were shuttered for maintenance.  The report, which was presented at a California State Senate hearing on Nov. 15, also details that West Coast oil inventories were either increasing or remaining level at historic five-year averages during the price spikes this year. In addition, the national price of crude oil, the main driver of gasoline prices, was decreasing in October and May, complicating market fundamental explanations for the price spikes.  

Attorney General Holder created the Oil and Gas Price Fraud Working Group on April 21, 2011 to explore potential manipulation, collusion, fraud or misrepresentation that harms consumers in the oil and gas markets.  The Working Group includes include representatives from the Department of Justice, the National Association of Attorneys General, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the Federal Trade Commission, the Department of the Treasury, the Federal Reserve Board, the Securities and Exchange Commission, as well as the Departments of Agriculture and Energy.

“West Coast families and businesses are reeling from elevated and extremely volatile prices at the pump, impacting family budgets, inflation levels, and overall economic activity,” the Senators wrote in a letter to the DOJ. “We believe this situation demands the attention from the Working Group established in April 2011 specifically to “monitor oil and gas markets for potential violations of criminal or civil laws to safeguard against unlawful consumer harm.”

An extensive analysis of emissions monitoring data by McCullough found that the Chevron refinery in Richmond, Calif., emitted byproducts of petroleum production throughout May. Yet public reports claim the refinery shut down production from May 12 to May 26.

According to the McCullough report, the October price spike added up to a 66 cent-per-gallon windfall profit for oil companies – or about $25 million a day. The difference between what drivers actually paid and what they should have paid exceeded $1 billion.

“Taken together we believe these facts paint a picture of a highly unusual set of concurrent events in West Coast petroleum markets,” the Senators wrote in the letter. “Given the hit to American families and businesses from gasoline price spikes, we urge the Working Group to use every existing authority and regulation to identify, stop, and prosecute any and all instances of false reporting, manipulation, or anticompetitive behavior in the West Coast petroleum wholesale markets.”

The full text of the letter is below.

 

November 27, 2012

 

The Honorable Eric H. Holder, Jr.

Attorney General

U.S. Department of Justice

950 Pennsylvania Ave, NW

Washington, DC 20530

 

Dear Attorney General Holder:

We are requesting a Department of Justice investigation of possible market manipulation and false reporting by oil refineries which may have created a perception of a supply shortage, when in fact refineries were still producing.  A McCullough Research report released Nov. 15th in conjunction with a California State Senate hearing on California gas prices revealed information that showed that the price spikes in May and October occurred while crude oil prices were declining, inventories were increasing, and possibly in conjunction with misleading market-making information.  We hope the Justice Department and members of the Oil and Gas Price Fraud Working Group will launch a refinery-by-refinery level probe.

According to this new analysis by McCullough Research, supply shortages following refinery fires and other unexpected outages at West Coast refineries did not cause the May and October gas price spikes.  During these periods inventories were either increasing or remaining level at historic five-year averages during the highest price spikes.  In addition, an exhaustive review of California refinery emissions data revealed inconsistencies between when refineries were actually producing petroleum products and when maintenance shutdowns were publicly reported.  Potentially market-making information, misleading reports of shutdowns could create or exacerbate a perceived supply shortage and artificially drive market prices to unjustifiably high levels.  If these findings are accurate, which could only be confirmed through subpoenaed records, they would violate the FTC August 2009 Rule against “false or misleading public announcements of planned pricing or output decisions,” and be subject to fines of up to $1 million a day per violation.

West Coast families and businesses are reeling from elevated and extremely volatile prices at the pump, impacting family budgets, inflation levels, and overall economic activity.  We believe this situation demands the attention from the Working Group established in April 2011 specifically to “monitor oil and gas markets for potential violations of criminal or civil laws to safeguard against unlawful consumer harm.”  Anomalous, uncompetitive market dynamics may have forced West Coast drivers to pay $1.3 billion more at the pump during the May 2012 price spike than they should have, according to an analysis by McCullough Research.  Even a one cent per gallon increase in gasoline prices cost California consumers an extra $150 million per year, according to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).

Unfortunately, our constituents are all too familiar with energy market schemes that manipulate supplies to boost profits at the expense of consumers. We are still paying for higher electricity rates from the fraud perpetrated by Enron, Reliant, and others during the Western Electricity crisis over a decade ago.  Petroleum is a key part of our economy, yet these markets are opaque and highly concentrated making them inefficient and subject to market power abuse.  While we applaud the Working Group for convening in April 2011, we see scant evidence that its members are policing these markets as required by law or cracking down on other practices that may be illegal and hurting consumers.

It is important to note that because the West Coast refinery market is highly concentrated and isolated, inaccurate information about just one refinery being down can impact gasoline prices for tens of millions of consumers.

Taken together we believe these facts paint a picture of a highly unusual set of concurrent events in West Coast petroleum markets.  Given the hit to American families and businesses from gasoline price spikes, we urge the Working Group to use every existing authority and regulation to identify, stop, and prosecute any and all instances of false reporting, manipulation, or anticompetitive behavior in the West Coast wholesale petroleum markets.

The Working Group should aggressively utilize all of its members’ relevant statutory authority to remedy this situation.  That includes the Justice Department’s authority to prevent and prosecute fraud and collusion, the FTC’s authority to prohibit fraud or deceit in wholesale petroleum markets and the reporting of false or misleading information related to wholesale prices (42 U.S.C. 17301 - 17305); as well as the parallel authorities to prevent the use of any “manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance” granted to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)(15 U.S.C. 78j(b), 7 U.S.C. 13(a)(2), 15 U.S.C. 717c-1, and 16 U.S.C. 791a).

We commend FERC for effectively using the authority and responsibility granted by Congress in 2005 to actively police electricity and natural gas markets, deploying a well-qualified team of experts to oversee trading activity and analyze trading data.  Since January 2011, FERC has announced more than 10 probes into alleged energy market manipulation, including reaching a record $245 million settlement with Constellation Energy Group Inc., issuing a show cause order that Deutsche Bank’s energy trading unit manipulated the California power market in 2010, and recently proposing a record $469 million penalty against Barclays Plc for energy market manipulation.  As of October 2012, FERC has used its 2005 anti-manipulation authority to conduct 107 investigations resulting in 52 settlements and civil penalties of $294 million and disgorgement of profits totaling $155 million.

Thank you for your attention to this critical matter and we look forward to your timely response.

###